[Mb-civic] Iraq a Rerun of Vietnam
Reeeees at aol.com
Reeeees at aol.com
Mon Nov 7 16:28:52 PST 2005
Published on Monday, November 7, 2005 by the _Buffalo News_
(http://www.buffalonews.com/) (New York)
Tragically, Iraq Has Become A Rerun Of Vietnam
by Anna Quindlen
'Once again we were destroying the village in order to save it.'
The Vietnam Veterans Memorial is a tapering wall of black granite cut into
the grass of Constitution Gardens. Maya Lin envisioned a scar when she
designed it, a scar on this land, which is exactly right. Maybe someday his security
detail could drive George W. Bush over to take a look. He'll be able to see
himself in the reflective surface.
The list of names etched into the wall begins with a soldier who died in
1959 and ends with one who died in 1975. Nearly 60,000 dead are commemorated
here. It is the most personal of war memorials. You can touch the cold names
with your warm fingers.
The president never wanted the war in Iraq to be personal. His people
forbade photographs of coffins arriving home. They refused to keep track of how
many Iraqis had been killed and wounded. When "Nightline" devoted a show to the
faces of soldiers who had died, one conservative broadcast outlet pulled the
program from its lineup.
The president wanted this war to be about policy, not about people. Even
that did not go well. The policy became a moving target. First there were
weapons of mass destruction that were not there and links to the Sept. 11
terrorists that didn't exist. The removal of Saddam Hussein was given as the greatest
good; it has been done. Then it became the amorphous goal of bringing freedom
to the Iraqi people, as though liberty were flowers and we were FTD. The
elections, the constitution, the rubble, the dead. Once again we were destroying
the village in order to save it.
This all took an unfortunate turn for the administration during the
president's vacation in August, when Cindy Sheehan showed up at his ranch. Say what
you will about her politics or tactics, there was no doubt that she was a
mother whose soldier son was now dead, and wanted to know why. What was the
cause, the point, the strategy? And suddenly many Americans started to realize
that there was no good answer.
The Vietnam Memorial stands, in part, as a monument to blind incrementalism,
to men who refused to stop, not because of wisdom but because of ego,
because of the fear of looking weak. Not enough troops, not enough planning, no
real understanding of the people or the power of insurgency, dwindling public
support. The war in Iraq is a disaster in the image and likeness of its
The most unattractive trait of the American empire is American arrogance,
which the president embodies and which this war elevated. It is not simply that
we have a good system. It is the system everyone else should have. It is the
best system, and we are the best people. We can mend rivalries so ancient
that they predate not only our nation but the birth of Christ. We will install
the leaders we like in a country we scarcely understand, leaders who will
either be seen as puppets by their people or who will eventually turn against
us. We have been here before.
"In Vietnam we didn't have the lessons of Vietnam to guide us," says David
Halberstam, who won a Pulitzer Prize for his coverage of that war. "In Iraq we
did have those lessons. The tragedy is that we didn't pay attention to
Perhaps the leaders of the Democratic Party should take time off from their
fund-raisers and visit the Vietnam Memorial, too. They should remember one of
the most powerful men the party ever produced, Lyndon B. Johnson, and how he
was destroyed by opposition to the war in Vietnam and bested by those brave
enough to speak against it.
At least Johnson had the good sense to be heartbroken by the body bags. Bush
appears merely peevish at being criticized. Someone with a trumpet should
play taps outside the White House for the edification of a president who has
not attended a single funeral for the Iraqi war dead.
The number of American soldiers killed has topped 2,000. Will I be writing
these same things when the number is 3,000, 5,000, 10,000? If we are such a
great nation, why are we utterly incapable of learning from our mistakes?
America's sons and daughters are dying to protect the egos of those whose own
children are safe at home. Again.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Mb-civic